Every armour piece and weapon carries some mix of the five primary attributes: Strength, Agility, Stamina, Intellect, and Spirit. For the two builds in this guide, Agility is the one you should not give up. Stamina and Intellect share second place and change order in the 40s. Spirit only settles a tie, and Strength does nothing for a Hunter who shoots.
What each attribute does
| Attribute | What you get | What the pet gets | Verdict |
|---|
| Agility | 2 ranged and 1 melee attack power per point, plus critical strike: about 53 Agility for 1 percent at level 60, and fewer at lower levels | 10 percent of the attack power and all of the critical strike | Critical on every slot |
| Stamina | 10 health per point | 2 health per point | Second until 40 |
| Intellect | A larger mana pool. With Careful Aim at 5/5, which this build reaches at level 50, 1 attack power per point | Nothing until Careful Aim, then 10 percent of that attack power | Second from 46 |
| Spirit | Health and mana regeneration between fights. Bestial Discipline at levels 33 and 34 keeps half of the mana regeneration running while you cast | Nothing | Can be compromised |
| Strength | Melee attack power only | Nothing, because the pet reads whichever of your ranged and melee attack power is higher | Ignore |
These conversions are read from the game client, and Blizzard has confirmed none of them. Nobody has published Forever's amounts per point for Spirit or Strength, so those two rows follow the Classic rules.
Why Agility outweighs the rest
Compare one point of each. A point of Agility is 2 ranged attack power and some critical strike, and the pet copies that critical strike in full. A point of Intellect with Careful Aim finished is 1 attack power and no critical strike, so it takes more than two Intellect to replace one Agility. A plain attack power line is worth half its number in Agility, without the critical strike: 20 ranged attack power does the work of 10 Agility.
Agility is stronger still while you level, because each percent of critical strike costs less Agility below 60.
Guides agree that Agility comes first and disagree about what follows. ConquestCapped stops at "Agility comes first". WoW4Ever puts Intellect and Stamina together at the bottom for Beast Mastery. Gfinity ranks Intellect straight after Agility and does not rank Stamina or Strength at all. The order below is my own, worked out from the conversions in the table.
What is critical and what you can give up
| Levels | Critical | Second | Can be compromised | Ignore |
|---|
| 1 to 40, Beast Mastery | Agility | Stamina, then Intellect | Spirit | Strength |
| 41 to 45, Lethal Attacks | Agility | Stamina and Intellect equally | Spirit | Strength |
| 46 to 60, Careful Aim | Agility | Intellect, then Stamina | Spirit | Strength |
| 60 and raids, untested | Hit chance to the cap, then Agility | Critical strike, attack power, Intellect | Stamina, Spirit | Strength |
Stamina is second before 40 because the pet does most of the fighting and takes the hits. Each point is health for you and 2 health for the pet. Mana matters less while the pet does the damage.
Intellect moves ahead from 46. Each rank of Careful Aim turns another 20 percent of your Intellect into attack power, and at level 50 all of it counts. From there Stamina is the attribute to trade down, although Hardcore players should keep it second all the way.
Spirit is not worth paying for. Accept it when it comes on a piece that also has Agility. Stalker's leather has Agility, Intellect, and Spirit and covers levels 30 to 40, which is when Bestial Discipline starts to use Spirit.
Strength should never decide a choice. An item with Strength in place of Agility is built for a Warrior, even when it is mail a Hunter can wear.
Choosing armour
- Compare Agility first. The piece with clearly more Agility wins.
- If Agility is close, take the piece with more Stamina before 46 and more Intellect after.
- Count a plain attack power line as half its number in Agility.
- Use armour type and armour value last. You wear leather to 39 and mail from 40, and the pet takes 30 percent of your armour, but a mail piece without Agility is not an upgrade over leather that has it.
- Leave Spirit and Strength out of the comparison.
The Stalker's Mail Belt from Chapter 2 shows what a good piece looks like. Its 14 Agility is 28 ranged attack power plus critical strike. Its 10 Intellect is 10 attack power once Careful Aim is finished. Its 12 Stamina is 120 health for you and 24 for the pet. Nothing on it is wasted.
Choosing weapons
Judge the ranged weapon by damage per second before anything else. Every shot starts from the weapon's damage, and WoW4Ever places ranged weapon damage per second above every attribute in all three specialisations. Method makes the same point: weapon upgrades are worth more than other slots. Attributes on a bow or gun are a bonus, and a few points of Agility rarely make up for a weaker weapon.
The melee slot works the other way round. This build shoots, so melee weapons are there for their attributes. Choose them the way you choose armour, and ignore both the weapon's damage and any Strength on it. Hunters can use daggers, fist weapons, swords, axes, staves, two-handed swords, and two-handed axes from level 1, and polearms and dual wield from 20. To choose between a two-hander and a pair of one-handers, add up the Agility on each side.
At 60 the choice is closer. Forever Upgrades ranks the two-handed Legionite Glaive (16 Agility, 54 attack power, 10 hit rating) first for Beast Mastery, and the pair of Heartseeker and Ironwood Blade slightly ahead for Marksmanship.
Skyborne racials
Being Skyborne does not change the order. No Skyborne racial adds an attribute, hit chance, or critical strike. Both factions get Walk on Air, a small haste bonus from Wind Blessed, and 5 percent more damage to elementals. High Order Skyborne on the Alliance also have Read Leyline, which raises health and mana regeneration and does the job Spirit would do, so they have even less reason to gear for it. The Windshaper racial Skysight is run speed. The full racial table is in Chapter 10 of Leveling Up in Forever.
Hit chance at 60
Hit chance joins the list at 60. Method's hit guide gives 5 percent to stop missing creatures of your own level and 8 percent for raid bosses, and notes that its author could not test whether a 1 percent miss chance remains at the cap. Gfinity lists hit first in its raid priority. Hit and critical strike appear on level 60 items as ratings, such as the 14 critical strike rating on the Black Dragonscale Helm. No raid has opened, so treat the level 60 row of the table as a starting point.
Remember: Take Agility on every slot. Stamina comes second until 40 and Intellect from 46. Spirit only breaks ties, and Strength never decides a choice. Pick the ranged weapon by damage per second and the melee weapon by its attributes.